The Other Side Always Precedes: Growing, Developing, Protecting the Fruit and Once it has Grown, it is Cast Aside
“Yes, YHWH’s portion is His people [Jacob the parcel of His estate] (Deuteronomy 32:9)—a parable: A king had a field which he leased to land tenants. When they began to steal from it, he took it away from them and leased it to their children. When the children began to act worse than the first, he took it away from them and gave it to their grandchildren. Now a son was born to him and he said to them, ‘Leave my property. You may not stay there. Give me back my portion, so that I may repossess it.’ Thus when our father Abraham came into the world, פְּסוֹלֶת (pesolet), refuse, issued from him—Ishmael and the sons of Keturah. Our father Isaac came into the world, [and] refuse issued from him—Esau and all the princes of Edom who became worse than the first. When Jacob came into the world, refuse did not issue from him, but rather, all his sons were worthy, as is said, And Jacob was a simple man, a dweller in tents (Genesis 25:27)” (Sifrei, Deuteronomy 312).
“The powers of impurity emanate before the powers of purity, for at first the refuse is purified, and afterwards the powers of purity emerge. As is said, Remove the dross from silver, and for the refiner the vessel comes out (Proverbs 25:4). So it is with Cain and Abel, Cain came out first from the refuse which is on the left side, and afterwards Abel who is from the side of Ḥesed, Kindness. And similarly with Esau and Jacob. And it says: Esau came out from the dross of gold. Therefore, Isaac loved Esau for he came from his dregs….
And what is said that ‘He kept building worlds and destroying them [until He created these]’ (Bereshit Rabbah 3:7, 9:2), hints to the powers of impurity which emanated first and were nullified. And of this is written, who are shriveled before their time, their foundation pours out like a river (Job 22:16) [see BT Ḥagigah 13b–14a ad loc.; cf. BT Shabbat 88b; Bahir §195]” (MS Paris 859, 16a, 42a–43a).
And YHWH said to Samuel, “Look not to his appearance and to his lofty stature, for I have cast him aside. For not as man sees does God see. For man sees with the eyes and YHWH sees with the heart” (1 Samuel 16:7).
“As for the seed of David, the appearance of colors is reversed. Therefore Samuel erred, as is written: Look not at his appearance (1 Samuel 16:7), for the Other Side was in Eliab, which was not so in David” (Zohar 2:74a).
“At first, Er, firstborn of Judah, was evil (Genesis 38:7) similarly, Mahlon, but not as much. But by these, evil was consumed and good eventually emerged—the one of whom is written goodly to look on, and YHWH is with him (1 Samuel 16:12, 18)” (Zohar 2:103b).
“For Rabbi Abba has said, ‘How many wicked there are in the world who engender more virtuous children than the righteous!’” (Zohar 2:12b).
“Here is a mystery. In all actions performed by the blessed Holy One, He begins with the external, and then the kernel within…. The Other Side always precedes: growing, developing, protecting the fruit. Once it has grown, it is cast aside; What the wicked will prepare, the righteous will wear (Job 27:17)—that קְלִפָּה (qelipah), shell, is thrown away and the Righteous One of the world is blessed [cf. BT Pesaḥim 49b]….
Israel is the kernel of the world; Israel arose in thought. Other nations, who are the shell, preceded, as is written: These are the kings who reigned in the land of Edom before any king reigned over the Children of Israel (Genesis 36:31)” (Zohar 2:108b, Sava de-Mishpatim).